The question of whether Firestar caused the death of Cloudtail is a recurring one within the Warriors fandom. It’s important to state definitively that Firestar did not kill Cloudtail. The query stems from a misunderstanding or misinterpretation of events within the book series. There is no instance in the Warriors books where Firestar intentionally or unintentionally causes Cloudtail’s demise. Cloudtail’s ultimate fate is different.
The persistence of this misunderstanding highlights the emotional investment readers have in the characters and storylines of the Warriors series. Speculation and fan theories are common, and the longevity of the series allows for interpretations of events to evolve. The dynamic relationships between characters like Firestar and Cloudtail are fertile ground for such discussions.